Top Auto Insurance Companies in Atlanta, Georgia 2023 Updated

Insurance companies in AtlantaInsurance companies in Atlanta

Insurance companies in Atlanta

1.Atlanta Life Insurance Company

More than 100 years ago, Alonzo Franklin Herndon, a former slave, founded what would become the Atlanta Life Insurance Company. A sharecropper from Social Circle, Georgia, Herndon parlayed his haircutting skills into the finest men’s barbershop in Atlanta, catering to the white businessmen who populated Peachtree Street until his shop was damaged during the 1905 Atlanta race riots.

An indomitable entrepreneur, Herndon was a real estate investor, a world traveler, an amateur architect, and a pillar of black Atlanta — becoming its wealthiest black man. His mansion, built by black artisans in 1910, sits next to Morris Brown College and is listed on the national register of historic homes on Diamond Hill.

The company that Herndon founded — with a $140 investment — was the outgrowth of one of the many benevolent societies catering to low and moderate-income consumers. Salesmen sold the company’s low-cost industrial insurance door-to-door at a time when, perhaps, they were the only black men passing through a southern town wearing suits and ties.


Personal Insurance

Commercial Insurance

Group Reinsurance

Contact no:+1 888-407-3209

Address: 191 Peachtree St NE Suite #2500, Atlanta, GA 30303, United States


2.Loya Insurance Company

With over 726 Loya Insurance Group offices throughout Texas, Ohio, California, New Mexico, Colorado, Georgia, Nevada, Illinois, Arizona, Indiana, and Alabama we have a friendly neighborhood office near you.

Loya Insurance Group is a National leading provider in Automobile Insurance leveraging over 47 years of experience with operations in: Texas, California, New Mexico, Colorado, Illinois, Nevada, Georgia, Indiana, Alabama, Arizona & Ohio.

We provide our employees with Competitive Compensation Packages that include:

Health Insurance

401k Retirement

Life Insurance

Supplemental Benefits


And most importantly, a GROWING career path opportunity

Contact no:+1 678-701-6323

Address: 1459 Moreland Ave SE #3, Atlanta, GA 30316, United States


3.Starr Insurance Companies

We lead the way in our understanding of the unique insurance needs of international markets. Rely on our global experience and insight in an ever-changing world of risk, and build your business with the best in property, casualty, accident and health insurance solutions.

From our origins as the first American-owned insurance agency in Shanghai in 1919 to our current presence across six continents, Starr Insurance Companies has grown into an industry powerhouse — built on 100 years of international literacy and operational knowledge.


Aviation & Aerospace

Business Travel




Food & Beverage

Government Contractors



Contact no:+1 404-946-1400

Address: : 3353 Peachtree Rd NE #1000, Atlanta, GA 30326, United States


4.New York Life Insurance Downtown Atlanta

At the heart of New York Life is a commitment to be there for our customers when they need us—whether today or decades into the future. We have delivered on that promise for 175 years by investing wisely, growing a portfolio of strategic businesses, and remaining true to our mission as a mutual company, accountable only to our customers, not to outside investors. For our customers, that means having the confidence that comes with knowing they can build a better future for themselves and those they love.


Life Insurance

Retirement Income

Long-Term Care


Premier Services

Contact no:: +1 770-730-2000

Address:  55 Ivan Allen Jr Blvd NW #835, Atlanta, GA 30308, United States


5.Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Company®

Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Company® is a provider of a competitive line of life and supplemental health insurance products, 

For 65 years, we have had the honor of supplying the individual and senior market with a comprehensive suite of products and responsive service. We understand our customers’ needs and aim to help provide them with the peace of mind they deserve. At Bankers Fidelity, we know the value of going above and beyond to ensure that every policyholder’s desires needs are met.Our record of bringing innovative products and value-added services to market has established us as a proven leader in the life and health insurance industry. Therefore, you can rely on our reputation as a company that delivers on its promises to our policyholders.


Medicare Supplement Insurance

 Short-Term Care Insurance

 Final Expense Life Insurance

Lump Sum Cancer Insurance

 Hospital Indemnity Insurance

Contact no:+1 800-241-1439

Address:  4370 Peachtree Rd NE #3008, Atlanta, GA 30319, United States


6.American Southern Insurance Co

Provider of Policies, Protections and Peace of Mind.

Since 1937, American Southern has provided commercial auto insurance to companies of all sizes, spanning all industries. From school systems to utility companies, we’ve brought coverage and peace of mind to thousands.

AM Best has affirmed the Financial Strength Rating (FSR) of A (Excellent) and the Long-Term Issuer Credit Ratings (Long-Term ICR) of “a” of American Southern Insurance Company (Topeka, KS) and its wholly owned and 100% reinsured subsidiary, American Safety Insurance Company (collectively referred to as American Southern Group).

We are looking for Partners that believe in The Promise.

Mark Thomas heads up the marketing efforts at American Southern. In his 25+ years in the insurance industry he has acquired significant experience in underwriting, marketing, sales, risk management, claims and even loss control.

If you have a current P & C program or an idea for a program to serve an underserved market or niche please call Mark to discuss the opportunity.  He loves to discuss mutual opportunities.

Contact no:+1 404-266-9599

Address: 3715 Northside Pkwy NW, Atlanta, GA 30327, United States


7.GEICO Insurance Agent

I started working with GEICO in 1999 and opened my Atlanta-based GEICO insurance agency in 2006. Our agency is dedicated to providing outstanding customer service to citizens in Metro, Southwest, and Southeast Atlanta. We can help you with Atlanta insurance for your car, home, renters, motorcycle, or personal watercraft insurance. We also work closely with the Georgia Underwriting Association to help get insurance coverages for homeowners with a history of prior insurance claims.

I served in the U.S. Air Force for 24 years before joining GEICO, and I achieved the rank of Chief Master Sergeant. I understand the unique insurance needs of Military personnel, and can also help you with GEICO’s Military discounts.

Products Offered

Auto Insurance

Motorcycle Insurance

Homeowners Insurance

Renters Insurance

Condo Insurance

Mobile Home Insurance

Boat Insurance

ATV Insurance

RV Insurance

Collector Car Insurance

Umbrella Insurance

Identity Protection

Personal Watercraft

Commercial Auto

Contact no: +1 404-472-9003

Address: 3680 Cascade Rd Suite C, Atlanta, GA 30331, United States


8.Peachstate Insurance

Atlanta, Georgia is a thriving city with a rich, interesting history. As the capital of Georgia and home of the Martin Luther King Jr. National Historic Site, Atlanta is a relatively low-cost area with high employment opportunities for residents as well as a wonderful tourist spot. For twelve years, Peachstate Insurance has served Atlanta and surrounding cities with affordable car insurance. We understand how congested the traffic becomes in Atlanta and the risk that car wrecks pose to drivers and pedestrians alike.

Although the cost of living can be affordable in Atlanta, car insurance is unfortunately more expensive here than any other city in Georgia. This is because of its high population and congested highways, and the rates only seem to be climbing as more people move into the city.



Business Auto



Recreational Vehicle


Contact no:+1 404-624-1190

Address:  1917 Pryor Rd SW #2c, Atlanta, GA 30315, United States


9.Colonial Life – Insurance

Colonial Life understands how disruptive it can be when the unexpected happens. That’s why we’re here to support the ever-changing worlds of our clients and their employees.

In 1937, Edwin F. Averyt and J. Clifton Judy started Mutual Accident Company in South Carolina with a goal of providing people with financial protection in times of unexpected need. Since then, our company, products and team have expanded significantly, but Averyt’s and Judy’s mission has remained the same every step of the way.

Now a subsidiary of Unum Group, our team of more than 10,000 sales representatives and 1,200 home office professionals serves more than 3.7 million people in over 90,000 companies and organizations.1

Solutions for

Individuals & Policyholders

Employers & Plan Administrators

Brokers & Consultants

Contact no:+1 770-392-8581

Address: One Riverside 4401, Northside Pkwy NW Suite 710, Atlanta, GA 30327, United States


10.MagMutual Insurance Company

While we continually innovate, evolve and grow to stay ahead of a changing healthcare environment, our core precepts remain steadfast and our commitment to them unwavering.

MagMutual is committed to improving the healthcare environment for medical providers and the quality of care for patients. Through our charitable Foundation and political action committee, we work to enact meaningful change and make a positive difference in the communities we serve.



Education & Learning

Attorneys & Consultants


Preserve Program℠


Contact no:+1 800-282-4882

Address: Bldg 14, 3535 Piedmont Rd NE, Atlanta, GA 30305, United States


Tajinder Singh: